Innocence of Muslims – how would Rasūlullāh react?



That any true Muslim feels hurt at this latest assault on the honour of the Beloved Nabī صلى الله عليه و سلم needs no elucidation. The same would hold true for any honest person that the West has double standards when it comes to freedom of speech. Attack Islām, that’s fine, but question “the holocaust,” Darwinism or the claim that human civilisation is only 6000 years old, you could face a range of punishments from imprisonment, academic character assassination or loss of a job.

Now let us stop imitating the Jews as we do with so many other things. Stop moaning, “Oh! The world is against us and we are so helpless and innocent!” Let us ask what does the faith we profess to follow ask us to do in these trying situations.


1       Respond to slander with facts, not emotion

When we are attacked, we always respond emotionally and forget the actual argument. This is contrary to the principles of the Qurān. For example, when the Quraysh accused Rasūlullāh صلى الله عليه و سلم of acquiring the Qurān from a monk, not Allāh, the response was not, “How dare you accuse me, when you know I am truthful!” Instead, the reply was a clear logical statement that the monk was a foreigner who could not possibly compose the fluent Arabic of the Qurān.

Indeed We know that they say, “A man teaches it to him!” The tongue of him to whom they wickedly refer is foreign, whilst this is a clear Arabic tongue. [an-Naḥl: 103]

2.       Adversity is an opportunity to increase  good deeds

Indeed We know that your chest is constricted because of what they say. But you should instead recite the purity and praise of your Lord and be amongst those who prostrate. [al-Ḥijr: 97-98]

Thus if adversity and grief led Rasūlullāh صلى الله عليه و سلم to increase in good deeds, how are we exempt? Let us do some soul searching and ask if running around screaming, “Death to America,” benefits the image of Rasūlullāh صلى الله عليه و سلم in any way. Is it not embarrassing that the West can smugly say, “See! We accuse their Prophet of violence and they respond with violence!”

If I truly love Rasūlullāh صلى الله عليه و سلم should I not act in the light of the above verse and increase my recitation of salutations [Arabic: Ṣalawāt; Persian: Darūd] upon Rasūlullāh صلى الله عليه و سلم ? The Hadith teaches us that angels convey our greetings to him. Would that prove more profitable to our relationship to him when we meet on the Day of Qiyāmah or would “Death to America”?

Practically, how does my life and appearance conform to the man I claim to be honouring with my protests? Does my lifestyle resemble his, or that of the filmmakers? Condemning others is always easier than trying to reform oneself.

3.       No soul bears the burden of another [az-Zumar: 7]


Did the US ambassador make the film, or even know about its production? Please pray tell how we justify such killings in the name of the religion of peace. Perpetuating disbelief is worse than the shedding of blood. May Allāh save us from such acts which serve no purpose other than to tarnish the image of Islām and repulse people who might otherwise have been inclined to it. 

4.       There are etiquettes to dialogue
Uncouth behaviour from others does not excuse us from obeying the Qurān, especially when we are directing our response at parties innocent of the movie, “Do not debate the People of the Book except in a better way, except for those amongst them who do wrong.” [al-‘Ankabūt:46].

When the Jews, thinking themselves to be smart, greeted  Rasūlullāh صلى الله عليه و سلم with a blurring between, “as-salaamu alaykum,” (peace be upon you) and “as-saamu alaykum” (death unto you) our Mother, Aishah رضى الله عنها became furious. Rasūlullāh صلى الله عليه و سلم however remained calm and replied, “And on you.” Whatever they intended was replied to without resorting to their manners. 

Rasūlullāh صلى الله عليه و سلم courteously addressed foreign dignitaries including the Byzantine Emperor, Heraclius Caesar, whom he addressed as, “Heraclius, great of Rome.” Make no mistake – Heraclius was a far greater enemy of Allāh than George Bush could ever dream of.  Rasūlullāh  صلى الله عليه و سلم clearly declared that by rejecting Islām, Heraclius was to condemn his Empire to disbelief. The burden of the rest of Europe, the Americas, Australia etc is the eventual result of him rejecting the truth despite knowing it. Yet he was not deprived of due courtesy.
Not only have we shamed Islām in the murder of a foreign dignitary, we have helped erase the accomplishments of our forefathers. There are academics in the West who are honest enough to admit that the entire concept of International Law and certain of its specifics were born from Islāmic jurisprudence. Would those jurists have justified the slaying of an innocent diplomat? The fruits of their labours have been erased.

5.       Rasūlullāh صلى الله عليه و سلم was practical and looked at the bigger picture
When they were about to sign the Treaty of Ḥudaybiyah, the Quraysh objected to the phrase, “Muḥammad, the Messenger of Allāh.” They would only consent to, “Muḥammad, son of ‘Abdullāh.” The Muslims were most upset, and refused. Rasūlullāh صلى الله عليه و سلم  however personally erased the phrase. He knew that there were bigger issues at hand.
Muslim historians record that as a result of his foresight, obstacles to preaching Islām were removed and more people entered Islām in the following two years than in the previous 19 years of Islām. That would not have been achieved had Rasūlullāh صلى الله عليه و سلم been stubborn over the wording of the Treaty. He had vision and looked at the bigger picture.
The bigger picture for us is that even this filth could have had one positive aspect of creating curiosity amongst disbelievers. We could have seized the opportunity to explain the beautiful character and teachings of Rasūlullāh صلى الله عليه و سلم to our friends, colleagues, neighbours and the media. Instead we reveal our ignorance about the greatest personality who has the most detailed biography ever in human history. How many Muslims can describe this personality to their neighbours for even 5 minutes?

The words,  “Muḥammad, Messenger of Allāh,” holds a special place in the heart of every Muslim, but let emotion not cloud our judgement and make us lose our opportunity of Ḥudaybiyah and the deeper message of Muḥammad صلى الله عليه و سلم

To negate Jihaad is disbelief, but remember that there are various forms of Jihaad. Feel hurt, but follow his example.

سليمان الكندي

Advertisements

5 responses

  1. Very well-written. However, and while i do not condone the senseless violence, I think the response by Muslims needs to be contextualised. The insult to Rasulullah Sallallahu Alayhi Wasallam is the latest in a litany of humiliations heaped upon the Ummah over the last three hundred years. From the humiliation that was colonialism, which involved not only the subjugation of Muslim lands militarily, but also the replacement of the centuries old Islamic education and legal systems with corresponding Western methods and codes, to the fragmentation of the Ummah into nation states and the even more recent invasions, insults and blanket oppression, Muslims have an inner frustration that finds release in violent responses to provocations such as these. While the approach taken is no doubt intensified by a lack of legitimate and unifying leadership that could have channelled that anger in a more constructive avenue, it is perhaps true that protesting in this manner makes Muslims feel, for even a short span of time, like the heroes of past times who defended the lands of the Ummah from foreign invaders, as opposed to our pitiful and helpless current condition. Th key point is that merely telling Muslims what the correct response is, is not in itself going to make us react differently the next time we are provoked, if no viable steps are taken to establish legitimate leadership that will guide us in the future.

  2. I think that the point that Sheikh was trying to make is that it is understandable that Muslims across the world are frustrated about these contstant attacks against the Prophet (SAW). (There is a French newspaper that is planning to print more insulting cartoons of the Prophet (SAW), let us hope that our reaction is not the same). What is important is the way we react to these clear provocations. Should we proceed to do exactly what the Kuffaar want us to, or do we follow a more dignified approach, as suggested.And it is not "merely telling Muslims what the correct response is", it is advice from the Ulama, which is clearly needed in these times, which will at least make us aware that what we are doing is not what should be done. We cannot wait for legitimate leadership before we start acting the way Islam teaches us to…

  3. Brother Umaru, as salaamu alaykum. Jazakallah khayran for your response.As usual your vision is deeper and penetrates to core issues, rather than just the external symptoms. No doubt, core issues have to be addressed, but in view of the titanic task, weaker ones such as myself sometimes have to make do with the here and the now. That does not mean I disagree with those focussing on the core issue.A man issued 5 divorces to his wife. When approached by the family I realised the core issues were them living in isolation from Muslims, lack of contact with Ulama, inability to communicate, self-centredness etc. I could not address those issues, and could only advise on the irrevocable nature of the divorce, just as another 3 scholars also did. Yet because the core issues could not be addressed, the "couple" is still living together.

  4. Jazakallah khayran for taking the time to comment. If I may rephrase your closing comment – let us keep the higher ideal as the aim, but start off by practicing what is within our capacity.

  5. […] What we should reflect on is how often we as Muslims react with raw emotion instead of looking at the facts. I have touched upon this issue previously when discussing our reaction to the video, Innocence of Muslims. […]

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: